INTRODUCTION
Innovation, competition, and technology are all influenced when a patent expires, plus it takes a concrete step in the lifecycle of an invention. When a patent expiration occurs, what this means is that the monopoly granted to the patent owner is removed, which informal means that anyone can now use, make, sell, or distribute the invention without seeking the owner's permission or required to pay the royalty charge. By transferring the invention into public domain it is helpful for other business firms and inventors to get an knowledge to develop similar type of invention or an invention of higher value this helps the competition to boost up hence helping to come down the prices. Further, the research provides that relative accessibility of the beforehand patented technology contributes to the increase of the level of its diffusion and application in different industries and regions for the benefit of the society. Furthermore, the process of patents expiring means that there is new opportunity for advancement on that original invention since there are no legal hurdles to counter this innovation. This process has general importance for further developments in technology and improvements of the economy. Thus, patent expiration provides for a fair distribution of stake in the inventions and innovations both to inventors and the rest of society, as while the inventors receive a specified time of monopoly over their invention to earn back their investment and make profits, the invention gets to circulate within the society.
SIGNIFICANCE OF PATENT EXPIRATION
Patent expiration has been an important topics due to the effects it has on innovativeness, competitiveness and availability to technology. That is the moment at which the invention the patent aims at protecting becomes common property so to say, meaning that any other party can use, make, sell or distribute the invention without request for authorization or paying license fees. This has several important implications:
Fostering competition: Market competition is promoted by the expiration of patents where the inventors and other businesses introduce products or technologies similar to or better than those newly patented. This is because it fosters competition, leads to lower costs and an increase in available brands in the market.
Facilitating technology diffusion: Technology diffusion and adoption detail after the expiration of a patent ensures that invents become easily available leading to greater usage in different industries and countries. This is true as networks can cause the quick diffusion of new technologies that are known to be advantageous to everyone.
Encouraging follow-on innovation: Innovation take off occurs where patent expiry leads to lowering of barriers by disaffirming any further work in that area to the original patent owner. This can cause further development and enhancement of technology which can lead to the creation of more innovations.
Balancing public and private interests: This limited patent protection period also aims at ensuring the protection of the inventors while at the same time preventing monopoly by these inventors and companies. On the one hand, patents make people invent and eventually make those inventions available to anyone willing to pay the required amount of money and to use them exclusively for a given amount of time, after which everyone is free to use them as they wish, in a social interest.
PATENTS AFFECT INNOVATION AND COMPETITION
Patents influence innovation and competition profoundly through the protection of exclusive property rights granted to inventors and they last for a limited number of years, often 20 years from the date of filing. This exclusivity encourages inventors to agree to licensing by offering them the means to earn back their investment in research and development along with the potential to turn a profit on their inventions, thus promoting new inventions. However, patents also affect innovation and competition in several other ways:
Incentivizing innovation: Patents are legal rights granted to inventors that enable them to gain profits from their inventions for a fixed number of years. This also fosters research and development, spreads innovation and promotes creativity and resourcefulness.
Promoting technology disclosure: In support of this view, inventors are required to provide comprehensive information about their inventions through the patent application process. A party gaining access to new technologies and inventions in a certain field will be able to contribute to the advancement of the knowledge and understanding of the relevant field by making it publicly available.
Fostering competition: On one had, patents vested in inventors and their assignees exclusive rights to the invention but, on the other hand, the same have introduce competition because other inventors of business entities are motivated to come up with a better solution or an improved version of the existing invention. This situates the market into one that is characterized by high levels of innovation in products and technology.
Preventing imitation: Patents are important to inventors because they offer security to a creation by preventing other competitors from copying it, and this effectively offers inventors an opportunity to retain an edge over players in the pool.
Facilitating technology transfer: Patents help to underwrite licensing and joint venture arrangements so that inventors or their employers can delegate development and marketing responsibilities to others. This makes it easier to transfer technology from one inventor, researcher or industry to the other and also improve on inventions.
INTERNATIONAL ASPECTS TO PATENT PROTECTION
Patent protection has some international elements as most inventions are not only developed, marketed, but also are used in different countries. On an international level there are a number of treaties and conventions that deals with the protection of patents and fosters a harmonised legal framework across the world. Some key international aspects of patent protection include:
Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property: The Paris Convention was signed in 1883 and is one of the oldest, as well as the most significant international treaties in terms of IP and patent protection. It concerns the reciprocal validity of patents, and lays down certain minimum criteria for patenting protection, such as the priority right.
Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT): PCT stands for Patent Co-operation Treaty and it is under WIPO – World Intellectual Property Organization PCT provides for the filing of an international patent application instead of filing patents in different countries at one time. Because many applicants prefer to file applications for more than one country, this increases efficiency and saves money.
European Patent Convention (EPC): The EPC affords inventors patent protection in multiple European countries by only filing a single application to the European Patent Office. This also helps in ensuring that there is protection of inventions within the region and also encourages inventions and use of technology in the European Union states.
Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement: The TRIPS Agreement is an international agreement of WTO that concerns minimum standard of intellectual property rights that must be offered to the home country by the member countries and it also includes the requirement of providing effective protection of patents and enforcement of the patent rights.
International treaties are also very relevant instruments that help advance cooperation in the sphere of innovation, support technology exchange, and ensure that the requirements set forth by national legislations for obtaining patents are mutualized. They afford greater legal risk to inventors in their quest for patent protection in foreign countries; so a promising innovation will further be invested in, thus helping breed advancement and commerce on a worldwide scale.
CAN PATENTS BE INVALIDATED?
There are many ways for completely invalidating patents, based on the proceeding or lawsuit nature that can be on patent office level or court proceedings. The act of invalidating a patent entails asserting that the patent is having no legal force and that the rights granted by the patent are no longer binding on the holders of the patent.
Some common grounds for invalidating a patent include:
Lack of novelty: If the subject matter of the invention claimed in the patent has been anticipated, or if it was prior in public domain prior to the filing date of the patent application, then the said patent may be declared invalid for novelty.
Lack of inventive step: Of which an invention may be invalidated due to the fact that they would have been an obvious step to follow for a person skilful in that certain field at the time the patent was filed, taking into consideration prior art.
Lack of industrial applicability: In some cases, there is a doctrine that the object of a patent is not allowable as it cannot be utilized in an industrial manner, which leads to the invalidation of the same patent.
Insufficient disclosure: It has to explain how to carry out the invention, and a skilled person in the particular filed in which the invention is made should be able to follow instructions without spending inordinate amount of time to do so. However, if the patent specification fails to disclose enough information to the public, then certain companies may seek to have the patent declared as having been rendered invalid.
Fraud or inequitable conduct: A patent may be declared unenforceable in view of fraud or inequitable conduct, instances where the applicants withheld material information before the patent office or made misstatements.
The process of invalidating a patent tends to occur through litigation and by making a comment or allegation in the court or in the patent office. Sometimes, it could be necessary to prove the reasons for its invalidity citing such and make the decision-maker withdraw the grant of the patent. Cancellation of a patent may not only entail what it directly involves between the parties to the losing patent but also any activities related to competition in the market, advancement of technologies, and protection of intellectual property.
PATENTS & ECONOMY
Patents play a role, in boosting the economy through means;
- Encouraging innovation and investment; Patents motivate inventors and businesses to invest in research and development by granting them rights to their creations for a period. This encourages the development of products, processes and industries.
- Driving growth; Patents support growth by facilitating the introduction of inventions to the market and the establishment of new enterprises. Innovations protected by patents enhance productivity create employment opportunities and generate income through licensing deals, royalties and product sales.
- Drawing investment and talent; Effective patent protection attracts investment funds and skilled professionals to sectors as investors and entrepreneurs look for ways to leverage intellectual property assets. This encourages activity fosters competition and strengthens economies on a scale.
- Encouraging technology exchange and collaboration; Patents establish a framework for sharing technology among inventors, researchers and industries. Through licensing agreements partnerships and joint ventures knowledge is shared leading to innovation commercialization that promotes technology diffusion, across sectors and regions.
Patents are crucial, for fostering progress encouraging innovation driven expansion and boosting the competitiveness of countries, in today's knowledge based economy.
CONCLUSION
Yet the expiration of patents plays a critical role in this ecosystem since it enables, promotes and accelerates the level of competition, technology diffusion and follow-on innovation that ultimately improve products and services, reduce costs, increase choices and progress broader access of these inventions and to all types of technological progress. Upon patent expiry, invention proliferation enters a vibrant marketplace where multiple companies can build on the same inventions to create better products and services. These follow-on products can bring immense value to society, be it by increasing consumer choices, lowering prices, or improving usability. Additionally, more companies entering the market with lower input costs can lead to the greater distribution of new technologies to more regions and industries. The benefits to society could be immense. Patent expiration further sparks new innovation, such as by liberating knowledge and resources to build new creations, thus endlessly perpetuating this cycle. By its very nature, the limited term of patent protection creates a necessary reciprocity – acting as a trade-off between rewarding inventors and serving the public interest. Patent expiration promotes sustained levels of economic growth, technological progress and innovation across all sectors of our societies. To optimise the value of patents and better harness the mindset of inventors, stakeholders can learn to benefit from patent expiration.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.