As mergers and acquisitions activity increases in 2024, middle-market dealmakers evaluating an exit and corporate founders planning for CEO succession are considering a variety of factors, including employee motivation, retention, incentives, interest rates, post-pandemic valuations, and tax laws. In a sale of the founder's equity to an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), the interests of corporate employees and founders should align. The founder of a private corporation approaching retirement age and seeking to retain management control may consider selling equity in intervals while establishing a tax-efficient ESOP, concurrently strengthening employee engagement.
Although Congress enacted employee ownership tax incentives in 1974, employee ownership models are receiving increased attention as private equity advocates and academics have publicly championed social and economic benefits of employee ownership. This GT Advisory evaluates four reasons why an ESOP may be an attractive option in 2024 for a middle-market founder's exit and succession planning, while establishing an employee ownership stake and potentially enhancing corporate profitability through tax incentives.
1. Staging the Sale of the Corporation to an ESOP. In a higher-interest-rate market, ESOP sale structures have changed from those customary five years ago. Consider the founder of a middle-market corporation nearing retirement with no apparent successor CEO to lead the business. The founder desires to gradually transition the CEO function, continue managerial and board oversight of the corporation, establish family succession planning and prepare for retirement while building shareholder value and providing employee incentives, all on the founder's timeline. Unlike other M&A financial or strategic sales of the business, the founder's sale of shares to the ESOP retirement plan can be staged in intervals over a number of months or years.
2. Succession Planning for Founder. The founders of a closely
held corporation may consider employee ownership as an alternative
option to a sale to a financial or strategic buyer that is driven
primarily by economic and financial strategic factors. The closely
held owner's decision to sell may, on the other hand, be
equally or more influenced by other factors such as family dynamics
and the need for long-term stability in the employee ranks. Through
careful planning with ESOP tax specialists, the founder executive
may sell his or her qualified shares in a corporation taxed as a
C-Corp to an ESOP by electing Internal Revenue Code (IRC) 1042
capital gains tax deferral treatment and reinvesting the sale price
of the corporation in qualifying replacement property. This tax
deferral enables investment diversification for the founder's
retirement and estate planning.
3. Financing Warrants. ESOP transactions may be structured for
founders to retain equity incentives. Warrants may be used in the
transaction to provide founder-sellers with additional value in
consideration for debt financing of the transaction in the form of
lower-interest-rate seller notes. The terms of the warrants are
carefully designed to avoid overly dilutive terms affecting the
ESOP valuations. Providing warrants to selling shareholders align
founder incentive for corporate growth with the ESOP and the
employee-owners and can save the corporation significant cash flow
immediately following the closing.
4. Post-ESOP Sale Corporate Governance Flexibility. Founder-selling
shareholders typically retain their board seat and management
functions, ensuring stability during the transition period
following the ESOP sale while the seller continues to have capital
at risk in the corporation. The ESOP-owned company board of
directors governs the corporation with oversight from a trustee
that is a fiduciary for the retirement plan. The plan trustee may
be directed or discretionary. A directed trustee follows the
instructions of the board of directors, although they must also
demonstrate in taking direction the exercise of good judgment that
is proper in terms of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act
of 1974 (ERISA). A discretionary trustee, conversely, acts
independently of the board of directors and CEO and makes decisions
independently as a fiduciary for the ESOP. Independent
(non-management) directors are often appointed to the board of
directors within several months of the sale to the ESOP. Audit,
compensation, and ESOP committees are frequently a framework for
board governance, with independent directors assuming committee
roles involving reports to the board and trustee and determining if
potential conflicts of interest are being identified and reviewed.
Many founder-owned corporations do not have this type of corporate
governance prior to a sale but should implement proper corporate
governance when the corporation is sold to an ESOP.
An ESOP is a form of employee retirement benefit plan governed by the IRC and ERISA, designed to invest primarily in securities issued by the employer. Although closely held business owners ready to sell do not always consider an ESOP transaction, studies show ESOPs have significant potential to create economic stability, generate significant retirement benefits for employees, and increase corporate growth while enabling business owners to secure a gradual exit and a source of liquidity. It is possible for an ESOP-owned corporation to be exempt from federal income tax once the corporation is 100% owned by the ESOP.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.