In Australia including NSW, individuals convicted of a crime have the right to appeal their conviction and/or sentence. This process is crucial for ensuring justice. It also allows time for correcting any errors that may have occurred during the trial.
In this article, we are going to explain an overview of the rights to appeal in NSW. Additionally, we will provide detailed information on the:
- rights,
- process,
- and tips for navigating the appeals system.
Rights to Appeal
In NSW, the right to appeal a criminal conviction or sentence is enshrined in various pieces of legislation. For example, it includes the Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001.
The right to appeal is also an essential part of the criminal justice system. Basically, it allows for the review of decisions to ensure fairness and accuracy.
Who Can Appeal?
In NSW, defendants and the crown can appear decisions.
- Defendants: Individuals convicted of a crime have the right to appeal their conviction, sentence, or both.
- The Crown: The prosecution can appeal against a sentence if it is deemed too lenient but cannot appeal a not guilty verdict by a jury.
The Appeal Process in NSW
The appeal process in NSW varies depending on the court where the original trial was held. Here is a detailed breakdown of the appeal process at different court levels:
1. Local Court Appeals
Appealing to the District Court:
- Conviction Appeals: If convicted in the Local Court, you can appeal to the District Court. This is known as a conviction appeal.
- Severity Appeals: You can also appeal the severity of the sentence imposed, known as a severity appeal.
- All Grounds Appeal: If appealing both the conviction and the sentence, it is called an all grounds appeal.
Process:
- Notice of Appeal: File a Notice of Appeal within 28 days of the conviction or sentence. If this period is missed, you can apply for an extension of time, but this must be done within three months.
- Hearing: The appeal is usually a rehearing of the evidence presented in the Local Court. The District Court judge will review the transcript, exhibits, and submissions from both parties.
2. District and Supreme Court Appeals
Appealing to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal (NSWCCA):
- Indictable Appeals: Appeals from the District or Supreme Courts are heard by the NSWCCA. These are known as indictable appeals.
Process:
- Notice of Intention to Appeal: File a Notice of Intention to Appeal within 28 days of the conviction or sentence. This notice lasts for six months, during which you must file the formal Notice of Appeal.
- Notice of Appeal: File the Notice of Appeal, including grounds of appeal, written submissions, and supporting documents, within 12 months of the Notice of Intention to Appeal.
- Hearing: The appeal is heard by three judges who review the trial transcripts, submissions, and any new evidence if permitted. The judges will determine if there was an error of law or a miscarriage of justice.
3. Appeals to the High Court of Australia
Appealing from the NSWCCA:
- Special Leave to Appeal: To appeal to the High Court, you must first obtain special leave. The High Court only hears cases of significant public importance or where there is a substantial question of law.
Process:
- Application for Special Leave: File an application for special leave to appeal within 28 days of the NSWCCA decision. This application must demonstrate why the case is of significant importance or involves a substantial question of law.
- Hearing: If special leave is granted, the High Court will hear the appeal. The High Court's decision is final, and there is no further avenue for appeal.
Tips for Navigating the Appeals Process
- Seek Legal Advice: Appeals are complex and require a thorough understanding of legal principles and procedures. It is highly recommended to seek advice from an experienced criminal lawyer who specialises in appeals.
- Act Quickly: There are strict time limits for filing appeals. Ensure you file the necessary documents within the specified time frames to avoid missing the opportunity to appeal.
- Prepare Thoroughly: Gather all relevant documents, including trial transcripts, exhibits, and any new evidence that may support your appeal. Detailed written submissions outlining the grounds of appeal are crucial.
- Understand the Risks: Be aware that if your appeal is unsuccessful, the court may increase your sentence. Discuss the potential risks and benefits with your lawyer before proceeding.
- Consider Fresh Evidence: In some cases, new evidence that was not presented at the original trial can be introduced during the appeal. This requires the court's permission and must be shown to be in the interests of justice.
Right to appeal
The right to appeal a criminal conviction or sentence is a fundamental aspect of the justice system in NSW. Understanding the appeal process, from the Local Court to the High Court, is essential for anyone considering an appeal.
By seeking expert legal advice, acting promptly, and preparing thoroughly, appellants can navigate the complex appeals process and seek justice.
Need a criminal lawyer in NSW?
The legal system can be complex and overwhelming. Let us help you navigate it.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.